[meteorite-list] Russian Meteor: How Many Tiny Asteroids Buzz Earth?

From: Ron Baalke <baalke_at_meteoritecentral.com>
Date: Thu, 17 Oct 2013 12:37:31 -0700 (PDT)
Message-ID: <201310171937.r9HJbWYm025347_at_zagami.jpl.nasa.gov>


Russian Meteor: How Many Tiny Asteroids Buzz Earth?
By Ian O'Neill
Discovery News
October 17, 2013

The meteor that exploded over the Urals region of Russia in February was
a violent reminder that our planet exists in a cosmic shooting gallery.
Now, astronomers are focusing on these mysterious small and possibly dangerous
objects in the hope of understanding what they are made of and what kind
of threat they pose in the future.

Though rare, impact events by objects like the estimated 56- to 66-foot-wide
(17 to 20 meters) chunk of space rock can cause serious damage to populated
regions. The city of Chelyabinsk suffered around 1,200 injuries and millions
of dollars' worth of property damage when the shock wave from the disintegrating
meteor hit the ground - what if this happened to another city like New
York, London or Moscow?

The fireball that lit up Russian skies on Feb. 15 became the "poster child"
for asteroid impact mitigation strategies and drew attention to the underfunded
asteroid surveys that are currently our only defense against marauding
near-Earth asteroids, or NEOs. It also invigorated new research into the
mysterious population of tiny asteroids that may not wipe out countries,
but still give populated regions a very bad day.

In new research headed by Amy Mainzer, of NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory
in Pasadena, Calif., a population of NEOs smaller than 330 feet (100 m)
wide that invade our planet's orbital space were studied using data from
NASA's Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE). Taking their cue from
small asteroid discoveries made by ground-based visible light surveys,
106 previously unreported infrared observations of small NEOs were analyzed.

Inspired by the Chelyabinsk event, Mainzer and her team set out to survey
this poorly understood population of small NEOs. "What can we learn from
these objects, particularly the small ones? What is the smallest object
that we could see with WISE?" Mainzer asked.

Small, fast and hard to track

WISE was used to carry out a wide-field survey of asteroids before the
mission was put into hibernation in Feb. 2011 - a survey known as NEOWISE,
of which Mainzer is principal investigator. The software used to analyze
the NEOWISE data was set up to confirm the detection of asteroids that
were observed five or more times, in order to avoid registering false
positives such as transient events like cosmic ray hits on WISE's optics.

However, due to their close proximity to Earth and, therefore, their apparent
high speed, many of the fastest asteroids were observed on fewer than
five occasions. The researchers decided to delve into the archived data
to recover the small NEOs that are known to exist (as they were discovered
by other telescopes), but were observed fewer than five times and therefore
ignored as a true detection by the NEOWISE software.

Small objects zooming through the WISE field of view at relatively close
distances can be tricky to track, a situation Mainzer likened to a speeding

"When you see a train from far away, it doesn't seem to be moving very
fast, but when you stand right next to it and it zips by you...now it
looks like it's moving really quickly," Mainzer told Discovery News.

Many of these objects zoomed past the Earth at only a few Earth-moon distances,
but their infrared signatures could still be used to evaluate the physical
characteristics of these rocks.

Tiny dark asteroids

One of the key findings of their work, which has been accepted for publication
in the Astrophysical Journal (available also on the arXive pre-print service),
is that visible light surveys likely have a bias against detecting small,
dark asteroids.

"When we look at the visible light-selected sample - tiny NEOs discovered
by ground-based surveys - we see a distinct trend: the smaller you go,
the brighter the objects appear to be," said Mainzer. "We know that visible
light surveys are going to have a hard job of discovering objects that
are both very tiny and very dark because they are faint to a visible light

When analyzing the selected NEOs (discovered in visible light) through
WISE's infrared data, they found that it's likely that no such bias exists
in infrared wavelengths.

Visible light surveys basically work by detecting the sunlight reflecting
off asteroids' surfaces. From visible light data, some idea as to the
composition can be deduced. However, infrared observations can reveal
the physical size of the NEOs and the amount of heat that the asteroid
is losing to space. The researchers noted that there is a strong relationship
between heat flux (i.e. the thermal energy being emitted by the asteroids)
and their physical sizes.

Also, there is little correlation between heat and reflectivity. In other
words, if two asteroids are the same size, a bright asteroid will emit
about the same amount of heat as a dark one. Therefore, an infrared telescope
is roughly equally sensitive to dark and bright asteroids, whereas the
dark asteroid looks fainter in visible light.

This observation alone gives pause for thought. If visible light surveys
are biased toward seeing only the brightest (high albedo) space rocks,
are a whole population of dark (low albedo) NEOs being under-detected?

In short, we just don't know.

"With our previous NEOWISE studies, we found that about a third of NEOs
larger than 100 meters are dark. It's possible that a population of smaller
dark asteroids exists, but we don't have the right sample to test that
theory with what we've done so far (in this research)," said Mainzer.
"In my opinion, it is probable that a similar fraction of small NEOs are
dark, but the visible surveys are biased against finding them. They do
find some ... but not many."

Could the scarcity of small, dark NEOs be caused by some physical process
that preferentially produces small, highly reflective asteroids?

"There could be some physical process, but there's no solid evidence one
way or the other right now."

Visible vs. infrared surveys

This bias against finding small dark asteroids could be the Achilles Heel
of visible light surveys and needs to be considered before arriving at
any definitive conclusion as to the population of small NEOs. But, as
Mainzer pointed out, visible light surveys are highly complementary to
NEOWISE-like infrared surveys.

"If you have infrared surveys alone, you get a pretty good idea of diameters,"
she added. "But you can't say anything about the reflectivity of the surfaces
in visible light. So you need a combination of visible light plus infrared
together to really nail down the reflectivity, which gives you an important
clue as to the asteroid composition."

Chelyabinsk 2.0?

All of the objects studied by Mainzer's team were classified as NEOs,
a number of which are also potentially hazardous asteroids (PHAs). PHAs
are objects that make a minimum orbital approach to Earth's orbit of 0.05
AU (astronomical units; 1 AU is the average distance between the sun and

"It doesn't mean that the object and Earth will be in the same place at
the same time, but it does mean their orbits get close to one another
making this a population of interest," said Mainzer.

Interestingly, a couple of objects in this population are also identified
as "potentially accessible targets" - asteroids that could, someday, be
accessible by a future manned mission.

On considering the impact of the small Chelyabinsk object earlier this
year, it is perhaps sobering to realize that while around 90 percent of
NEOs with diameters larger than 0.6 miles (1 km) are thought to have been
discovered, less than one percent of asteroids the size of the Chelyabinsk
meteor (17-20 meters in diameter) have been detected.

Going back over NEOWISE detections of small NEOs acted as an experiment
in an effort to understand the correlation between visible light and infrared
surveys, but more work is needed to fully understand the composition of
these mysterious small threats to Earth.

In the near term, the hibernating WISE spacecraft is currently undergoing
a restart operation that will bring it back online in the not-so-distant
future to recommence its NEOWISE program. More detections of small NEOs
will allow better statistical calculations to be made, refining our understanding
of the visible light observation bias, ultimately making us better at
detecting any incoming space rocks that have our planet in their cross

Publication: The Population of Tiny Near-Earth Objects Observed by NEOWISE,
Mainzer et al., 2013. arXiv:1310.2980 [astro-ph.EP]

This article was provided by Discovery News.
Received on Thu 17 Oct 2013 03:37:31 PM PDT

Help support this free mailing list:

Yahoo MyWeb