[meteorite-list] RSVP re Valera - documentation?

From: Michael Blood <mlblood_at_meteoritecentral.com>
Date: Mon, 21 Nov 2011 09:53:53 -0800
Message-ID: <CAEFD031.1FFD5%mlblood_at_cox.net>

Hi Darryl,
        Thanks for the added info.
        Can you tell us if the material "out there" is from the actual
Hammer stone that killed the cow - or is some of it so and the rest
>From additional "rocks" of the fall?
        This would be valuable to know.
        Thanks, Michael

On 11/20/11 11:03 PM, "Met. Darryl Pitt" <darryl at dof3.com> wrote:

>
>
> VALERA REVISITED
>
> Hi,
>
> While not among my favorite stories, as you'll soon discover---I have no doubt
> whatsoever Valera killed a cow. In brief, there was far more data collected
> than the affidavit (which was one person's mere summary of events).
>
> Here's the story:
>
> Shepherded by Marty Zinn---the impresario of the Tucson Mineral and Fossil
> Shows---Valera was first offered at the Macovich Auction 11 or 12 Tucson's
> ago. Professor Ignacio Ferrin---a Venezuelan astronomer...and quite the
> gentleman....acquired the meteorite after word of its existence wound its way
> to him. Marty heard from Professor Ferrin who directed him to me, and he
> consigned Valera to our auction.
>
> For those who are unaware, the clavicle of an otherwise healthy cow was
> shattered and odd stones---only much later determined to be meteoritic---were
> found near the carcass. The sonic phenomena associated with a meteorite fall
> were experienced. Two large fragments from one mass were recovered (~35 and
> 7.5 kg), and left outside, one of which was used as a doorstop over a period
> of years---I imagine the lighter of the two. A third smaller specimen which I
> vaguely recall as being pretty much complete had been brought inside and was
> quite fresh. The specimens in circulation come from the larger fragments.
>
> Professor Ferrin gathered far more information other than his procurement of
> the affidavit. He has long been exasperated by the ongoing questioning of
> Valera's "killer" provenance by the meteorite collecting community, and has
> gone on-record addressing this topic more than once.
>
> There are two important points worth mentioning here---both of which are
> rather ironic.
>
> 1. It's important to recall that Ferrin was informed that the farm owner on
> whose property the meteorite fell, physician Argimiro Gonzalez, didn't think
> anything at all of this event. Dr. Gonzalez was well aware that rocks fell
> out of the sky, and so it seemed entirely reasonable to him that such impacts
> would occasionally result in fatalities. Without the rocks ever having been
> analyzed, Gonzalez, and later his family, considered the rocks as
> extraterrestrial curiosities---a conclusion which resulted from a dead animal
> which had been pulverized by blunt force trauma whose instrument rested
> nearby. It was the simplest explanation and somewhat a different tack than
> would be taken by the meteorite community: simply expressed, Gonzalez
> concluded as a result of a death that what he had must be a meteorite. It was
> many years later that Ferrin heard the story, confirmed Gonzalez's hypothesis
> and facilitated Valera's classification.
>
> 2. Every few years I have to admit to having undermined Valera's exceptional
> provenance, and here's how:
>
> The larger of the two massess did not sell at our auction (it was a big rock
> and pricey---while extremely inexpensive on a per/gram basis) and Ferrin
> suddenly found himself in an unexpected financial bind. He did not have
> particularly high expectations for how much it should sell---but he absolutely
> expected it would sell, and now he was stuck---and he didn't want to take 40+
> kg of rocks back to Venezuela. I felt badly as I was confident it would sell,
> and informed Ferrin of the same prior to his decision to bring Valera to
> Arizona. So I decided I would purchase it---but by doing so I now put myself
> in a huge financial pinch. So what did I do? The most foolish thing I've
> ever done in meteorites: while I don't recall the precise numbers, I sold a
> portion of the rock to another dealer for about my cost...perhaps a dollar a
> gram, as I recall, and then we both sold Valera super-cheaply.
> Percentage-wise we made a nice return, but the fact is that by having offered
> it so ine
> xpensively, a perceived valuation was created for a meteorite that should be
> selling today for easily $250+/g.
>
> If you have a specimen of Valera---treasure it. If you don't have one, you
> might consider getting some from somewhere as the price has been rapidly
> escalating of late. This past June at a Heritage Auction, a 309 gram specimen
> sold for $5,975 or about $20/g. I'm informed that small specimens today
> typically sell for $25/gram and more---and as you know, getting from $2.50/g
> to $25/g is the hard part.
>
> I'll never forget when I was on the exhibit floor at a Bonhams sale a couple
> of years back and someone declared, "I don't think Valera killed a cow---it's
> selling for MUCH too little for having done so." That was such a funny notion
> to me...how MY screw-up fueled an inaccurate impression. (I did not mention
> my role to the fellow ;-)
>
>
> All the best / Darryl
>
>
>
>
> On Nov 20, 2011, at 12:51 AM, MexicoDoug wrote:
>
>> Dear List;
>>
>> I have a question about the cow killing incident.
>>
>> The meteorite fell in 1972. I understand from rumors that it is absolutely a
>> confirmed cow killer. But the document doesn't read as an absolute fact, but
>> rather circumstantial evidence (which as a meteorite collector appreciating
>> the size of the mass I want to believe quite strong).
>>
>> The affidavit was signed in 2001, after the Doctor on whose property the
>> meteorite landed had died.
>>
>> Yet when I heard this, it was explained to me that a doctor had pronounced
>> the cow dead and there was injury visible on the cow caused by the falling
>> mass (a 50 kg stone). I always thought that a Doctor actually swore to the
>> wound on the cow and was convinced it was caused by the stone, since a doctor
>> would be expected to have a good idea of what such a wound would look like.
>>
>> This thread just prompted me to me read the affidavit. It doesn't say
>> anything about wounds on the cow.
>>
>> The affidavit was by the Doctor's visitor, and specifically does not even
>> mention that the doctor made any opinion about the meteorite killing the cow.
>> But does mention the doctor had owned the property and passed away
>> subsequently. No one from the Doctor's family, just the visitor, Juan
>> Dionicio, commenting 30 years later says it "appeared" (presumably him since
>> he doesn't mention the doctor) the cow was killed by the rock when he saw it
>> the next day. It does not mention any injuries or wounds to the cow at all.
>> Just "it appeared the cow had been killed by the rock" and also that "the cow
>> then eaten".
>>
>> Yet I heard at the time I bought this that the cow had sustained a mortal
>> injury the injury I recall being described at one point. Why this is not in
>> the document? ... has me thinking something must be missing?
>>
>> Is this the only document that discusses the claim of a cow being killed?
>> Because it seems to me people have much more information than is contained in
>> the affidavit. (But I've run up enough against rumors to believe that it's
>> easily possible for the rumors to just be taller tales down the line). Was
>> there a newspaper article in the 70's or anything predating this, or were
>> there any other witnesses besides Juan Dionicio, the mysterious guest who it
>> sounds spent several nights on the good doctor's ranch? I'd really like to
>> know.
>>
>> Kindest wishes
>> Doug
>>
>> ______________________________________________
>> Visit the Archives at
>> http://www.meteoritecentral.com/mailing-list-archives.html
>> Meteorite-list mailing list
>> Meteorite-list at meteoritecentral.com
>> http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list
>
> ______________________________________________
> Visit the Archives at
> http://www.meteoritecentral.com/mailing-list-archives.html
> Meteorite-list mailing list
> Meteorite-list at meteoritecentral.com
> http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list

--
Going to church doesn't make you a Christian any more
than standing in a garage makes you a car.
 
         

Received on Mon 21 Nov 2011 12:53:53 PM PST