[meteorite-list] AD: Wisconsin Fireball Meteorite Fall Part Slices on Ebay NOW 1 day

From: Galactic Stone & Ironworks <meteoritemike_at_meteoritecentral.com>
Date: Sat, 24 Apr 2010 09:04:43 -0400
Message-ID: <q2ue51421551004240604t3cc0ad18wf5be56ff684b164a_at_mail.gmail.com>

List,

Jason said :

>>> "Bullcrap. I'd like to see you point out a single place online or
otherwise where you can buy Ash Creek, Park Forest, or Whetstone
Mountains for anything shy of $20/g. Don't delude yourself here; as a
collector, I would *love* to see prices down there, but it's simply
not true. Park Forest is a standard $35-40/g, Ash Creek has bottomed
out at $20/g (sometimes 15 if you're lucky), and Whetstone, with its
comparable tkw (at the moment) is holding fast at $80/g or so."

I've bought Ash Creek and Park Forest for less than $20/gram - on more
than one occasion for each. Of course, I am not going publicly state
where I bought it - because I want to go back and buy more.

All of the falls you mention are OC's and only worth typical OC prices.

Best regards,

MikeG


On 4/24/10, Shawn Alan <photophlow at yahoo.com> wrote:
> Hi
> Where should I start......
>
> I guess ill start off where it was last left off at....
>
> Quote un quote
> "But don't trust me - I've only been here watching the market since 1998."
>
> Yes this true, and don't trust me either cause I just been watching the
> market since 2010.
>
> If I was in this situation that the meteorite collectors are in the field I
> would explain to the farms the case with what could happen with falls. What
> I would do if I was there I would split the finds 50/50 and give them the
> resources of how they could sell the meteorites or purchase the meteorites
> at a base value of current market value prices that reflects that type of
> meteorite fall in the market.
>
>
>>So you're suggesting cutting every stone found from the fall?
> Wow. I think there are many list-members here who would agree that
> that's a very, very bad idea. It's one thing to pay them a fair
> price. It's another to do so in such a way that you manage to destroy
> every stone found.
>
>
> So you are saying cut every stone from the fall....No, you said that. I
> merely gave some suggestions, it is your call on how you would like to
> interpret it. But.... if you want to cut them up into small pieces, then by
> all means do so, but please, don't try to ask a question and then answer
> your question with a quote un quote "Bullcrap" assumption.
>
> Lastly, I guess the bottom line is that by giving suggestions from different
> view points leaves open for how someone wants to take the information, if
> you want to take it as positive or nagative, by all mean do so. As for me, I
> like to be in the middle and play both sides, cause at the end of the day,
> it comes down to what your purpose is on here on the List is.... if it may
> be that your a collector, dealer, a middle man, to a hobbyist,scientist, a
> drive by reader or a nubie, just at the end of the day, make sure you leave
> with a sm;)e.
>
> Shawn Alan
>
>
>
>
> [meteorite-list] AD: Wisconsin Fireball Meteorite Fall Part Slices on Ebay
> NOW 1 day
> Jason Utas meteoritekid at gmail.com
> Sat Apr 24 07:01:11 EDT 2010
>
>
> Previous message: [meteorite-list] AD: Wisconsin Fireball Meteorite Fall
> Part Slices on Ebay NOW 1 day
> Next message: [meteorite-list] Wisconsin meteorites for sale
> Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]
>
>
>
>>I see Steve?s point of what he?s doing by setting a base price for the
>> recent meteorite fall in WI to pay the land owners %50 in cash from sales
>> on eBay. But, with any new fall the first year the price tends to be high
>> because it?s a new fall and there after the price drops to about $10 a
>> gram or less, unless it?s a hammer or has any significance because of
>> science or other reasons that could make a certain fall unique.
>
>
> Bullcrap. I'd like to see you point out a single place online or
> otherwise where you can buy Ash Creek, Park Forest, or Whetstone
> Mountains for anything shy of $20/g. Don't delude yourself here; as a
> collector, I would *love* to see prices down there, but it's simply
> not true. Park Forest is a standard $35-40/g, Ash Creek has bottomed
> out at $20/g (sometimes 15 if you're lucky), and Whetstone, with its
> comparable tkw (at the moment) is holding fast at $80/g or so.
>
>
>>In the case with the WI fall it is hard to say what significance this fall
>> has, then it?s another ordinary chondrite fall and until the scientist are
>> able to run more test on the fall.
>
>
> It's a brecciated, equilibrated H-chondrite. That much is obvious
> from the photos. I suppose it might be a funny L, but it looks like
> an H. Regardless, it's an equilibrated ordinary chondrite.
>
>
>>If I was in this situation that the meteorite collectors are in the field I
>> would explain to the farms the case with what could happen with falls.
>> What I would do if I was there I would split the finds 50/50 and give them
>> the resources of how they could sell the meteorites or purchase the
>> meteorites at a base value of current market value prices that reflects
>> that type of meteorite fall in the market.
>
>
> So you're suggesting cutting every stone found from the fall?
> Wow. I think there are many list-members here who would agree that
> that's a very, very bad idea. It's one thing to pay them a fair
> price. It's another to do so in such a way that you manage to destroy
> every stone found.
>
>
>>Good example is the NWA 869 L4-6 meteorite. At the current rate with this
>> ordinary chondrite, the going rate is $1 a gram or less depend on the
>> samples, if it has fusion crust, or if it?s sold as a Lot or not. With all
>> this could get confusing with the farm and if there scientific community
>> finds interesting finds, which could take a year or longer to verify could
>> change the current mark price.
>
>
> This fall's not going to be sold in bulk lots. Your analogy to 869
> does address quality, though...but I'm going to have to disagree with
> you here. Whether or not you're buying a fragment or an individual of
> a new fall from the US or Europe, you'll be paying $20-80/g. Give or
> take. That number generally depends on the availability of the fall
> -- not the individual specimen's quality. With more common falls,
> yes, quality makes a difference.
> A fragment of Gao is worth less than an individual because there are
> individuals available.
> But if you wanted a piece of...say, Homestead. There are no
> individuals on the market, and even slices and fragments are rare. In
> light of that fact, if you want a piece of it, the price per gram is
> fairly standard whether you're buying a slice, fragment, or
> individual.
>
> This is an American fall. Its price will be fairly standard, if it's
> at all like other American falls...Holbrook excluded because it's so
> large.
>
>
>>All in all I think this situation could go in different directions
>> depending on the comfort level the farmers have with the collectors or if
>> the collectors out in the field have a better understanding of what they
>> are dealing with from the fall.
>
>
> Just you wait until these ebay auctions play out...
>
>
>>At any rate its best to build a good level of communication with the
>> farmers of how the market works with new falls.
>
>
> Like with Ash Creek? I don't know if you were around for that, but
> the reason why things went sour so quickly is because dealers were
> paying farmers literally $1-2/g for stones that, in a few cases, later
> sold on ebay for $100/g (the price did drop drastically at the time,
> but held at $35/g for several months before coming down to the ~$20/g
> it is today).
>
>
>>Let?s say you have found a 300 gram meteorite from the fall and sat on it
>> for a few years and nothing became of this fall then just a ordinary
>> chondrite I would see the meteorite selling around a $1 a gram of less
>> depend if the weathering was down to a minimal and the structure of the
>> fusion crust was still intact and retained its physical characteristics.
>
>
> You don't seem to understand how western (N&S America, Europe, Asia to
> some extent) falls are priced.
> I would price the stone at between $4,000 and 5,000 dollars, and I
> would be damn happy to get it for as low as $4k.
> That's if this is a large fall.
> If it's a small fall like Whetstone...at least $5k, but the finder
> could easily ask for more. And get it.
>
> But don't trust me - I've only been here watching the market since 1998.
>
> Regards,
> Jason
>
> On Sat, Apr 24, 2010 at 12:43 AM, Brian Cox
> <searchingforfun at sbcglobal.net> wrote:
>
>> Uh, excuse me, Wait a minute, ok..... Something doesn't sound right here
>> at
>
>> all. I hate to be the buttinsky here and call anyone out, but as I
>
>> understood it all the collectors/dealer/.amateurs/locals HAD to PAY the
>
>> Farmers and Landowners Before They Left The Property with What They Found
>
>> and not 1 week or 1 month or 6 months or 1 year after they walked off the
>
>> property what money the meteorites were worth.
>
>>
>
>> Everyone PAID Upfront, not a day later nor next week or next month nor
>> next
>
>> year.
>
>>
>
>> People are reading about selling on ebay and then commenting that they
>
>> understand that the meteorites have to be sold so that you can "Pay the
>
>> Farmer" after they sell???? That is a Load of Crap.
>
>>
>
>> No one up there signed a contract with those landowners and farmers and
>
>> showed their Driver's license or gave them their address to wait for
>
>> payment. Those farmers are not idiots. They did NOT let anyone walk off
>
>> their land without paying up for what was found unless people hid
>> meteorites
>
>> or ran off the property like some guy did on Friday and then the farmer
>
>> chased everyone off and said no more hunting.
>
>>
>
>> All people up there HAD to Pay the farmer a fee such as $50 per day per
>
>> person to hunt and then you had to show your meteorites to the landowner
>> and
>
>> they weighed them and you had to pay at that time $4 per gram for your
>> half.
>
>> It was a 50/50 deal. If you had a 20 gram meteorite, then it was 20 x $4
>
>> =$80 and then you had to pay the farmer $40.
>
>>
>
>> If this isn't correct, then please correct me now, because this is what
>> 100
>
>> other hunters were doing and there is no Dumb Landowner that I know of
>> that
>
>> took anyone's word and is sitting back watching ebay to see how much these
>>
>
>> meteorites are going to sell for and is going to watch for the mail or
>> watch
>
>> Paypal for his half to magically appear.
>
>>
>
>> Aren't I right?
>
>>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Previous message: [meteorite-list] AD: Wisconsin Fireball Meteorite Fall
> Part Slices on Ebay NOW 1 day
> Next message: [meteorite-list] Wisconsin meteorites for sale
> Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]
>
>
> More information about the Meteorite-list mailing list
>
>
> ______________________________________________
> Visit the Archives at
> http://www.meteoritecentral.com/mailing-list-archives.html
> Meteorite-list mailing list
> Meteorite-list at meteoritecentral.com
> http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list
>

-- 
------------------------------------------------------------
Mike Gilmer - Galactic Stone & Ironworks Meteorites
http://www.galactic-stone.com
http://www.facebook.com/galacticstone
------------------------------------------------------------

Received on Sat 24 Apr 2010 09:04:43 AM PDT