[meteorite-list] Dealers, Sellers: Please INSURE your shipments

From: Gary Fujihara <fujmon_at_meteoritecentral.com>
Date: Wed, 03 Jun 2009 04:38:18 -1000
Message-ID: <3DA326B8-A460-48CE-8550-761DFA7D4906_at_mac.com>

Aloha listees,

I want to thank everyone who responded to my email. Many good points
were brought to my attention, so I thought I would condense them into
a sort of Reader's Digest version here:

* Many points of origin and destination offer no insurance for shipped
items. Unless you self-insure by some third-party underwriter ...
seems like a hassle though. (FWIW, the country of origin of my
shipment allowed insurance)

* Some dealers or sellers understate the value of their shipments to
reduce the tax burden on the buyer for international transactions.
But it is always as a dual agreement between the buyer and seller
before this is done.

* A high value declared on a shipment can slow down the delivery and
invite theft.

* A very good option for overseas shipments for very valuable
specimens are the courier services. A good option for very, very
expensive shipments is to deliver in person (anyone for a trip to
Hawaii? ;-)

* Never declare that you are shipping meteorites or even minerals - it
makes it too tempting to steal. A better strategy may be to declare
"Geological specimen for research", which is accurate but less
attractive to thieves.

* Use Paypal or a major credit card for transactions. Most have buyer
protection plans that can cover your loss (I don't know if I qualify,
but I have inquired).

* Purchases made on eBay or paid through Paypal are protected in the
same manner (I don't know if I qualify but I have inquired - keep in
mind that you can't double-dip from both eBay and Paypal).

* Always ship registered mail because the mail has to be signed for
each time it changes hands. No insurance is needed because it cannot
get lost. (well my package didn't get lost - it made it right to
me ... empty).

* For those of you who were wondering: No, I wasn't buying illegal
meteorites from Argentina - no Campos or Berduc.

* Keep all receipts, you need tangible evidence of the cost that you
paid (which could be problematic if you, the seller is also the finder
of the stones).

* On larger orders, the seller should recommend insurance to the
buyer, who may elect not to do so at his/her own risk. But give the
buyer the choice, make him an active participant in the shipment.

* There are inherent risks in doing business on the internet - caveat
emptor!

The current status of my lost shipment of meteorites from Argentina is
that I filed a Dispute with Paypal, which I escalated to a Claim. At
this point, Paypal has contacted the seller for information regarding
the shipment tracking information, after which it will review the
transaction and make a determination. Fingers crossed. Mahalo nui
loa (thank you very much) for everyone's responses and offers of
sympathy. Sympathy is okay, but my rocks would be better, and since I
will probably never see them in my collection, then the money I paid
to procure them would be a reasonable outcome that I can accept.

I hope this thread, and the information contained therein are of use
to both sellers and buyers. The best of luck to everyone in all of
your transactions and rock on!

gary


On Jun 1, 2009, at 12:59 PM, Gary Fujihara wrote:

> Aloha,
>
> I have been the victim of theft after discovering that over $1600
> worth of meteorites were missing from a shipment I received from
> Argentina. I had noticed the package felt light, but discovered
> that the US postal service is not responsible for thefts of the
> contents of international mailed items that are not insured. This
> shipment was not insured and so I will in all likelihood take the
> full brunt of this loss.
>
> Thievery by customs officials, foreign and domestic postal workers
> and other individuals or organized groups inside and outside the US
> is a possibility! I believe most packages arrive at their
> destinations with their contents intact, but feel it is negligent
> and at the very least unconscionable not to insure shipments at or
> above the full value of the contents. I know it costs more to do
> so, but please consider insurance especially for foreign shipments.
> Mailing specimen cards and paperwork separately from the meteorites
> can also prevent thieves from knowing what those "Mineral Samples"
> are.
>
> Is it fair for me, the buyer to take the loss alone for this theft?
> I personally don't think so, unless I was given a choice and elected
> not to insure. I would hope that the seller (an IMCA member who, to
> his credit is working with me) would have a sudden rush of
> conscience and compensate, or share the loss with me, since his act
> of omission provides me with little if any recourse. What are my
> rights, and what can I do? Do other dealers insure their
> shipments? What is SOP?
>
> Gary Fujihara
> AstroDay Institute
> 105 Puhili Place, Hilo, HI 96720
> (808) 640-9161, fujmon at mac.com
> http://astroday.net
>
> ______________________________________________
> http://www.meteoritecentral.com
> Meteorite-list mailing list
> Meteorite-list at meteoritecentral.com
> http://six.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list


Gary Fujihara
AstroDay Institute
105 Puhili Place, Hilo, HI 96720
(808) 640-9161, fujmon at mac.com
http://astroday.net
Received on Wed 03 Jun 2009 10:38:18 AM PDT