[meteorite-list] Dr. Bunch's Latest on NWA 1839/3133

From: Adam Hupe <raremeteorites_at_meteoritecentral.com>
Date: Sun Oct 15 17:47:28 2006
Message-ID: <03a801c6f0a3$728bfc30$6501a8c0_at_HPDESKTOP>

My last post on the subject,

I just had a lengthy conversation with Dr. Bunch just as few minutes ago
about the non-paired stones NWA 1839/3133.

Some statements made by Dr. Bunch:

He absolutely and unequivocally disagrees with David Weir's last post the
List.

He has access to the latest data and it in no way supports a pairing between
the two.

Dr Bunch's exact quote "The petrography, mineral chemistry and oxygen
isotopes clearly indicate that NWA 1839 and NWA 3133 are NOT paired, period!
bingo!"

I don't think it could be stated much clearer than that,

Adam







----- Original Message -----
From: "David Weir" <dgweir_at_earthlink.net>
To: "Adam Hupe" <raremeteorites_at_comcast.net>
Cc: <meteorite-list_at_meteoritecentral.com>
Sent: Sunday, October 15, 2006 1:12 PM
Subject: Re: [meteorite-list] [ebay] ending in about 2 days


> Adam Hupe wrote:
>> Stan,
>>
>> Let it go, you are absolutely wrong, again. Like I told David Weir,
>> contact Dr. Bunch yourself about NWA 3133 and report back to the List
>> your findings. Read the archives, it is all in there.
>
> Hello Adam,
>
> Thanks for inviting me into your debate. All I have to say is that I am
> 100% convinced that 3133 IS paired to 1839. This data IS NOT contained in
> the List archives, but I have a copy of it. Dr. Bunch has already been
> contacted and supplied this new data. Although he claims only to be a
> messenger, he has graciously taken it upon himself to arrange for new
> isotopic tests to be performed in light of this new irrefutable data (my
> words not his). If you are patient you will eventually know that these
> stones are paired. I will not supply you with my forensic data at least
> until you supply the List with yours, that which supports the hypothesis
> against such a pairing. Have a great day, I need to cook dinner.
>
> David
> meteoritestudies.com
>
Received on Sun 15 Oct 2006 05:47:01 PM PDT