[meteorite-list] puzzling Putorana

From: drtanuki <drtanuki_at_meteoritecentral.com>
Date: Thu Apr 22 09:54:10 2004
Message-ID: <3C77A0D9.CBB8A89B_at_tkc.att.ne.jp>

Dear Entropy and other Listees,

    On this one, I side with "gentle decay". Humbug, etc. to the knowledge
against the probability of physics! Dirk Ross...Tokyo

Dave Harris wrote:

> Hi there,
> I have just read Mr. Norton's article in this quarter's Meteorite magazine
> on Putorana where he speculated that the iron in the basalt was derived from
> mantle plumes conducting iron from the core to the magma chambers in the
> lithosphere - I was just wondering how actually plausible that mechanism
> actually was.
> I thought that a more likely scenario for the creation of Putorana iron may
> have been the effect of a magmatic plume coming into contact with a highly
> carbonaceous sedimentary deposit and the iron compounds are then reduced to
> native iron (much in the same way that commercial iron is produced by
> reacting with coke). I accept that the sedimentary deposits would have to
> be subducted to quite some depths before the appropriate temperature and
> pressures arose, but it still seems more likely a scenario to me than a
> outer liquid core streamer of iron travelling a couple of thousand
> kilometres upwards, against gravity and still keeping the iron in a liquid
> enough state to mix with magma.
>
> Any ideas? I wonder if there is any overriding chemical evidence that the
> iron is sourced from the core rather than liberated as part of a reduction
> of mantle silicates and oxides (possibly the presence of Ni in the iron is
> the evidence that supports the core theory - I dunno!)
>
> Don't laugh at me if I have written a load of rubbish here! I need to learn
> and only by thinking about this stuff and making gaffs will I learn
> anything - some of you people out there know more about Geology than I will
> EVER learn, so I bow to your undeniably profound knowledge!!!
>
> Ideas/opinions please!
>
> --
> In gentle decay,
> dave
>
> IMCA #0092
>
> imca_0092_at_hotmail.com (for IMCA member contact)
>
> http://www.meteorites.ic24.net/index.html
>
> http://www.meteoritecollectors.org
>
> "I have a proof that x^n+y^n=z^n never has integer solutions for n>2.
> However, it won't fit into my signature file...."
>
> ______________________________________________
> Meteorite-list mailing list
> Meteorite-list_at_meteoritecentral.com
> http://www.pairlist.net/mailman/listinfo/meteorite-list
Received on Sat 23 Feb 2002 09:02:02 AM PST